Friday, 20 November 2026


Ra(h)ul’s Split-personality Disorder



In that televised press meet to ‘accept people’s verdict’ in 2014 - 44 seats, down from 206 in 2009 - while Sonia looked crestfallen and her daughter Priyanka appeared gloomy, the real ‘loser’ Rahul seemed unconcerned. But still, even as he took the mike after his mother has done with it, she not only peremptorily stopped him from speaking but also pulled him by his hand signaling their exit. While the entire nation saw the mawkish 44 year-old meekly submitting to his haughty mother, none, as Sherlock Holmes would have put it, had ‘observed’ the abnormality of his personality.

It may be appreciated that when Sonia lost her man to Dhanu the suicide bomber, she was barely 44, her son was nearing 22, and her daughter crossed 19. What with her own flock back in Italy and not a friend to name in her in-law’s family, not to speak of detractors aplenty and leeches no less, in an alien country, where her political ambition made her stay put, she had to fend for herself and her children. So, as any widow would do in such a situation, she too succumbed to the urge of clinging to her son, at once providing support to him, and getting it in return from him, in the psychological sense that is. While that naturally made him a mama’s boy that his genes or fate and / or both rendered half-witted, only made it worse for him in his growing up.  But that’s not all as there’s more to his apparent ‘personality disorder’.

While his mother’s faith ensured that he was christened as Raul Vinci and privately reared as a Christian, his grandmother’s political compulsions labeled him as Rahul Gandhi. No denying the craven media was overindulgent to the family in not exposing this cynical reality to this day – in contrast with western media’s penchant to turn every Hindu fault line into an anti-Christian chasm - but it would be beyond any kid, least of all a dim-witted one like him, to change his religious cap to a political titfer and vice versa, at the drop of a hat, that too for years on, without disturbing his head. Surely, that did affect as is evident from his confused (Raul–Rahul) thought-process that runs on a course of contradictions - his words tend to be incoherent and his acts would be seemingly disjointed. Added to that is his confused demeanour, awkward behaviour and intelligible expression, and that leads to the supposition that Sonia willy-nilly enabled her unfortunate son to imbibe Dr. Dud ‘n Mr. Fraud split personality.

Added to his psychic dichotomy was the inimical influence of his mom’s moral turpitude, first brought to light by Bofors Kickbacks, and his exposure to the assorted skeletons in the family cupboard. It’s thus; his grow up afflicted his mental makeup and stunted his personality development; and so, in whatever he does or does not; his ‘personality disorder’ manifests itself in all its awkwardness, earning him derisive sobriquets such as Pappu ‘n Buddhu. If anything, his vain attempts to portray himself as a janeudhāri Hindu to varnish his and his party’s, anti-Hindu image for political marketing, made him seem a buffoon to boot.

Excerpted from the chapter ‘Italian Interregnum’ of the free ebook ‘Puppets of Faith: Theory of Communal Strife (A Critical Appraisal of Islamic faith, Indian polity 'n More) available in Pratilipi’

 

    
Character of Dr. Manmohan Singh 


While it was Annie Besant, the English woman, who helped the Congress form, Antonio Maino, the Dame de Italian, could cause its eventual liquidation. If not the maturity of the Indian electorate, at least the public allergy for the Congress’ insensitivity to the national ethos that she infused into her party apparatus could ensure that, and as and when that happens, it could be one of the many ironies of the chequered history of Hindustan. And for her part, even though Sonia has been unwittingly carrying on her man’s ‘work in progress’ of making the congress coffin for years, but yet, seemingly, it is their uninspiring son, who is probably destined to finish the job and put the final nail in it as well.

Let it be, but what about the man, who had unashamedly served Sonia’s devilish cause as her proxy premier for a decade?

In his belated address to the nation, as its Prime Minister, while dealing with the populist measures ushered in by him, ostensibly ordained by Sonia to pave the prime way for her son, he had no qualms in appropriating to himself the 1991 economic reforms that were indeed fathered by his mentor PV Narasimha Rao.

If anything, that was true to his character. 

But for Rao, who fostered him, by now he would have been a forgotten ex-governor of the Reserve Bank of India, one amongst many before him, not to speak of those who succeeded him. What a decent man’s morality would demand when his patron saint falls on bad times? Maybe, to leave the sinking boat is fine for a careerist politician but desertion wouldn’t be the in thing for any decent guy in his position, and that’s human morality is all about.

But what did the wily Sardarji do? With his mentor in dumps, he visualized greener pastures for himself in the shade of Sonia’s Bofors-tainted pallu. Well, it calls for no genius to foresee that the political dispensations of NDA ‘n UPA would have alternate reigns on the musical chair of the Dillii kursi and that when the latter’s turn comes; Sonia’s ‘foreign origin’ handicap would force her to concede the prized seat to someone else from her party ranks.

So what did the great survival artist do?

Not only did he distance himself from his lost out mentor but he unreservedly played the second fiddle to Sonia. Having privately ingratiated himself to her in every conceivable manner; he publicly declared that he’s not a ‘prime ministerial material’ in an idiot box interview, not once, but twice that was in case her ears fail to pick that up in the first instance. By the same token, Pranab Mukherjee paid the price for throwing his hat into the prime ministerial ring, presumably owned by the pseudo-Gandhis, not once but twice.

But then, what to make out of all that?

If he was secretly coveting the gaddi while publicly averring that he was not up to the mark, then he was cunningly self-serving. And if he genuinely believed that he was not a ‘prime ministerial material’ and still grabbed the job, then he was morally dishonest. Either way, he’s not a man of intellectual integrity or someone with moral conviction and /or both for which India has paid the price for having had him as its spine-less head for two decades. Maybe, he wouldn’t have coveted money for himself but all the same he served Sonia’s covetous causes and shamed the position of the Prime Minister, of the largest democracy on earth. That what made Modi famously characterize him as the one blessed with the art of bathing with a raincoat on him!

That’s not all; besides being servile to Sonia, the way he clung to his powerful seat, rendered powerless by her, disregarded by his own bureaucrats, disobeyed by his cabinet members, and humiliated by Rahul, he has ensured a premier place for himself in the Indian Hall of Infamy. But as he never seemed to have minded about his self-inflicted fate; he only should have known to what avail.  

And to cap it all, when his mentor’s mortal remains were being abused by the vengeful Sonia, who never forgave Rao for daring to cut her dynasty to size, he turned his shameless head the other way. Such was the personal character, political ethos, and the morality of mind of this cunning man, who had conned India as the benign face of Sonia’s rākshas regime.

Hence, Sanjaya Baru should have known better not to name his book on his times with him as The Accidental Prime Minister, which title befits only PV Narasimha Rao, for when the call came from the just-widowed Sonia, he had already packed his bag and baggage to move into his political vanaprastha, and not his ex-deputy, who had been cunningly paving his servile path to 7 RCR.

 

    


  




    Warts in Mahatma’s Atma

“Won’t it remind one of Gandhi’s experiments with truth?”

“I have no quarrel with Gandhi the man but I have problem with the Mahatma of his,” he said and as if to remonstrate his apathy for the Gandhian values, he had an extended sip of that Laphroaic.

“I’m no Gandhian and I don’t intend to be one,” he continued from where he had left. “But as is being done, I see it’s a disservice to his legacy to deify him; it’s when I approach him as man that I value him as a human being, but in his picture of mahatma, I see many a wart in his atma. Credit him for cleaning up the public toilets but why not condemn him for having forced his spouse to do the same; why laud him for his quixotic abstinence unmindful of his wife’s conjugal plight; was he not an inveterate autocrat in the democratic garb; what about his falling afoul of Prakasam, and how he played favorites with Nehru. Why bother about him as he’d been reduced for long as a political mascot of the slavish-minded of the self-serving Nehru family that hijacked his name to grind its dynastic axe! What an irony it is that his party that sundered the British yoke should have rendered the political reins into Italian hands? Bemoan the congress party.”

The above is excerpted from the author’s Glaring Shadow – A stream of consciousness novel and the following quote is from his prayer meeting on April 6, 1947, New Delhi, cited in the Collective Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 94, Sl. 243, pages 248/249.

“We should dispassionately think where we are drifting. Hindus should not harbour anger in their hearts against Muslims even if the latter wanted to destroy them. Even if the Muslims want to kill us all we should face death bravely. If they established their rule after killing Hindus we would be ushering in a new world by sacrificing our lives. None should fear death. Birth and death are inevitable for every human being. Why should we then rejoice or grieve? If we die with a smile we shall enter into a new life, we shall be ushering in a new India. The Concluding verses of the second chapter of the Gita describe how a godfearing man should live. I would exhort you to read and understand those verses and ponder over their meaning. You will then realize what our ideal is and how far short of it we are today. Our independence is at our threshold and it is our duty to ask ourselves whether we are fit to have it and sustain it.”

One may reflect the above silliness in Ambedkar's intellectual light underneath:

“Hinduism is said to divide people and in contrast, Islam is said to bind people together. This is only a half truth. For Islam divides as inexorably as it binds. Islam is a close corporation and the distinction that it makes between Muslims and non-Muslims is a very real, very positive and very alienating distinction. The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is the brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity. The second defect of Islam is that it is a system of social self-government and is incompatible with local self-government because the allegiance of a Muslim does not rest on his domicile in the country which is his but on the faith to which he belongs. To the Muslim ibi bene ibi patria is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin. That is probably the reason why Maulana Mahomed Ali, a great Indian but a true Muslim, preferred to be buried in Jerusalem rather than in India.”

 

 

Sunday, 1 November 2026


 

Musings Of The Muse

My 'Inside the Mind' in Unprompted Books
https://unpromptedbooks.com/author-in...

1) What inspired you to start writing?

In my teens, my personal feelings made their way into private letters, in mid-thirties, my workplace reflections found expression in my managerial articles and in late-forties my examined life began to lend itself to my fictional works to further foray into other genres.

2) What has been the most rewarding part of being an indie author?

Honestly, I haven’t become an indie author by choice, but under the compulsion of rejections, of my maiden novel, Benign Flame: Saga of Love, by every publisher to name. Besides, in that exclusive print period, unlike in these digital times, self-publishing was peremptorily dismissed as vanity publishing.

Whatever, after putting my first six in print to no avail, and when the digital platforms opened up, I opted to place my entire body of work on those as free ebooks. True, in spite of twelve books, in varied genres, under my literary belt, besides scores of articles, I largely remain an unheralded author in the world of letters. However, seeing that my oeuvre manages to swim through the literary ocean to reach some ebook readers that too to some acclaim of some of them, and that is my reward for being an indie author.

I’ve summed it all in my auto-biographical piece, “My ‘Novel’ Account of Human Possibility” thus: The possibilities of life are indeed novel, and seemingly my life has crystallized itself in my body of work before death could dissipate it.

3) What advice would you give to new or aspiring indie authors?

The twin components of writing, to better describe in Sanskrit, are bhasha (language) and bhava (becoming), the former, a product of reading, and the latter, a by-product of examined life. So, in so far as the fiction goes, its bhasha, unless accompanied by bhava, remains mere words that fail to impact the readers.

At the risk of repetition, I urge the aspiring authors to pause and let bhava make it happen them to write, however without any letup in their reading, going by the saying, one cannot become a good writer unless he has been a good reader.

4) How do you handle book promotion as an indie author?

I spare no digital platform that hosts free ebooks, but sadly, my means constrain me from publishing them on pay sites (justifiably so) such as this Unprompted Books.

5) What’s next for you? Are you working on a new book?

Well, there is nothing on the anvil now. But as individual creativity too has its own limits, maybe, I’ve reached mine as well; or simply it could be a combination of biological aging, (I’m running 79) and literary fatigue (of penning 12 books). However, I do come up with an occasional essay or an article, whenever my urge for expression, stirred by my restless thinking, compels me to reach the keyboard.

Sunday, 18 October 2026

Baring Faith to Uproot Belief

Agenda for Religious Reversions


That the jihadi Islam, to paraphrase in Telugu, has become the chaapa kinda neeru (stealthily spreading water under the mat) and its fidayeen lurk in every nook and corner of the globe, is a common knowledge for long. But yet, the non-Muslim world, despite the outsider advantage, remains clueless to confront, much less contain, this unremitting scourge. That is in part, geopolitics apart, is owing to an inadequate appreciation of this debilitating Islamic phenomenon, and this is but an attempt to address that lacunae.
So as to have the measure of this Islamic menace, one may gauge it through the mindset of Ijaz Khan Hussein of Pakistan, who survived the American military campaign against the Taliban in Afghanistan.

“We went to the jihad filled with joy, and I would go again tomorrow,’ he said. ‘If Allah had chosen me to die, I would have been in Paradise, eating honey and watermelons and grapes, and resting with beautiful virgins, just as it is promised in the Quran. Instead, my fate was to remain amid the unhappiness here on earth.” (The New York Times report cited by M.J. Akbar in his book The Shade of Swords) However, the power of the jihadi brainwash lies in the ironical fact that many a fidayeen happen to be virgins themselves, unexposed thus to the joys of sexual intercourse! The unusual sexual obsession of the believers, bordering on mania, is dealt with later in this piece.

It was Napolean, who purportedly proclaimed, “Give me forty men who are not afraid of death, and I will conquer the world”, but Muhammad dextrously perfected the psychic route to metamorphose his folks into fidayeen on Islam’s jihadi path. Though he did so in order to make them cement his political lanes, the mullahs allude the same as Allah-perfected Islamic path to paradise. Whatever, Muslims fail to realize that the Quran they revere was no more than Muhammad’s means to meet his ends that is despite Ayesha’s firsthand account, “I feel that your Lord hastens in fulfilling your wishes and desires."
Hence, it is incumbent upon the others to alert the believers that the Quranic ayahs, no matter whether they were Allah’s revelations, or Muhammad’s innovations, were the latter’s self-servings that forever bedevil their and their progenies lives. That is possible like never before in our information age but one needs a proper understanding of the Machiavellian tactics adopted by Muhammad to serve his selfish ends at the cost of his followers’ lives.

This is how it was.

After his flight to Medina, nay Yathrib, so as to sustain the nascent Islamic faith in his limited band of followers in the face of its ridicule by the neighbourhood Jews and Christians, he had set to turn the former against the latter in ayahs umpteen such as,

“The Jews and Christians say: We are sons of Allah and His loved ones. Say: Why then doth he chastise you for your sins? Nay, ye are but mortals of His creating. He forgiveth whom He will, and chastiseth whom He will. Allah’s is the Sovereignty of the heavens and the earth and all that is between them, and unto Him is the journeying.”

“O ye who believe! Choose not for friends such of those who received the Scripture before you, and of the disbelievers, as make a jest and sport of your religion. But keep your duty to Allah if ye are true believers.”

Just the same, not stopping at that, he stooped to set his greedy eyes on the wealthy Jewish hamlets to ravage which, the Spoils of War were good enough for him to egg his brigands, prompting Gibbon to dub Islam as a profitable religion. But it was when the mighty Meccans began to menace his Medina existence that he needed the dying to die ‘Napolean forty’ besides a new Quranic narrative to suit.

To start with, when his followers were a hapless bunch of seventy, his Quran in Mecca Surah, Ta Ha, 55.20, seemingly promised a promising afterlife right here,

“Thereof We created you, and thereunto We return you, and thence We bring you forth a second time.”

However, Medina’s changed circumstances made it imperative for him to downplay the inadequacies of life here and extoll the abundances in the hereafter that is besides substituting the premise of rebirth with the promise of permanence in the Paradise.

Hence, the Quranic stress,

“Naught is the life of the world save a pastime and a sport. Better far is the abode of the Hereafter for those who keep their duty (to Allah). Have ye then no sense?”

And then the Muhammadan chorus,

“O god, no good is but the good hereafter
So help the Helpers and the Emigrants.”

Not only that, not leaving the Hereafter to the limited imagination of his deprived folks, it was evocatively described in ways varied, such as,

"But those who believe and do deeds of righteousness, We shall admit them to Gardens under which rivers flow (i.e. in Paradise) to dwell therein forever. Allah's promise is the Truth; and whose words can be truer than those of Allah?"

Well, in Muhammad’s medieval period, maybe all this could have been an irresistible incentive but why should Muslims of the day deprecate their lives here that are better than the one pictured in Islamic paradise, is the puzzle.

Nevertheless, having altered the Islamic character of life and death, Muhammad rewrote its jihadi grammar thus:

“Warfare is ordained for you, though it is hateful unto you; but it may happen that ye hate a thing which is good for you, and it may happen that ye love a thing which is bad for you. Allah knoweth, ye know not.”

“Think not of those, who are slain in the way of Allah, as dead. Nay, they are living. With their Lord they have provision.”

So be it, but hypothetically speaking, can the followers of the other faiths be motivated to become martyrs based on the above premises, with their scriptures being what they are?
The answer would be an emphatic nay, and herein lies Muhammad’s ingenuous cunning in preparing the carnal ground for the fidayeen.

Well, Quran had unambiguously positioned him,

“Verily in the messenger of Allah ye have a good example for him who looketh unto Allah and the Last Day, and remembereth Allah much.”

And Quran hath it that Muhammad had given vent to his unbridled libido, laying bare his innate sexual urge that was after the aged Khadiza’s demise, resulting in multiple marriages culminating in the keeping of Mariyam. So, it is no wonder that sexual indulgence has endured as Islamic chivalry in the Muslim psyche. If anything, Allah allures the martyrs to His paradise thus,

“Enter the Garden, ye and your wives, to be made glad.”

“Reclining on ranged couches. And We wed them unto fair ones with wide, lovely eyes,”

And for the rest of his part, Muhammad further whetted the Islamic appetite for martyrdom by fixing the quota of these houris at seventy-two per head. What’s more, to make the heavenly bountiful meaningful to the sexually sceptical, he granted each one of them the strength of hundred men!

No denying, all that worked well for him in hoisting the Islamic flag in Mecca and the rest of the Arabia, and sadly, for much of the humanity, its latter-day flagbearers coerced many a cultured nation into its coarse order. What’s worse, overtime, the ummah came to be so structured as to make Islam ironclad that its hostility towards the others is perpetuated, sans scope for retraction and space for accommodation. And that made the cult a cureless virus to the world.

Nevertheless, with the laudable objective of modernizing this regressive cult that undeservedly acquired the religious tag, India’s Prime Minister, Narendra Modi had mooted the idea of the Madrasas with Muslim kids holding the Quran in one hand and a computer, an emollient replacement of the Islamic Sword, in the other. Well-meaning though, given the Quranic affect, in effect, it would be immensely damaging, as it could usher in multitudes of technically savvy fidayeen, leading to large scale manslaughters, aptly reminded by the flydubai episode. The fact that this fanatic cult strives to make all religion for Allah and aims to bring the world under a Caliphate, if ignored by the non-Muslims, it is bound to be catastrophic to the humanity at large.

So, it is high time to give up on ‘moderate’ Muslim hogwash of, Islam is a religion of peace, terrorism has no religion, all Muslims are not terrorists, Ummah is the worst victim of terrorism etc., and get real to the Quranic reality that it won’t let the believers live in peace and allow the others to live in harmony. However much the left-liberals wish, there can never be a via media in Islam – either one is a believing Mumin or a sceptical munafiq, with no in between moderate. Given that banning the Quran is academically implausible (restricting it in Masjids and Madrasas is eminently possible), baring the Islamic faith to uproot the Quranic belief is a viable proposition. Needless to say, all non-Muslims should join hands to lend their voices for exposing the Islamic inanities that give rise to Muslim abnormalities. Eventually, the body of munafiqs that such a campaign creates within the Ummah can be expected to bring the hegemony of the mullahs to a welcome end.

Just the same, the idea is not to make way for the evangelists into the Munafiq arena to harvest the disaffected Muslim souls but for them to return to Gibbon’s pre-Christian order of “the facility with which the most different and even hostile nations embraced, or at least respected, each other’s superstitions.” So, the agenda of religious reversions is for the potential renegades to revert to the religio-cultural dispensations of their respective progenitors, say, the subcontinental category to Sanatan Dharma and the Iranian variety to Zoroastrianism.

Author’s ‘Puppets of Faith: Theory of Communal Strife’ is a free ebook in the net.







Saturday, 3 October 2026








Semitic Faiths ‘n Sanatan Dharma: 

A Simple Study of Contrasts

While Christianity and Islam are hostile to the Jews but not to Judaism per se, their followers are antagonistic towards Hinduism, the Sanatana dharma of the Hindus, and for a good reason. Judaism being the father of the Abrahamic  faiths, denouncing it amounts to theological self-deprecation but as Hinduism is outside their monotheistic Semitic fold, running it down runs no such risk. Besides, weakening its polytheistic hold on a billion souls would soften the path of harvesting them for their bottomless religious granaries.

Even taking their proselytising urge in good faith – the Christian belief that without faith in Jesus, people stand condemned and the Islamic relief of a final truth to guide humanity - are their religious credos any better than the Sanatana dharma that postulates ekam sadviprā bahudhā vadanti (what is right is One only, describe it wise variedly) is the question that needs to be addressed for any rational study of contrasts among these diverse dispensations. Whatever, if Hinduism is a ‘Way of Life’, as ruled by India’s apex court, then it can be said that Christianity and Islam are the by-lanes of Moses’ Semitic Path, and  to comprehend the former, one has to go through the latter. However, it’s not much known that the oft-quoted "seeing is believing’ is the rational part of clergyman Thomas Fuller’s full quote, “seeing is believing, but feeling is the truth," that underscores this simple study of their contrasts.

To begin with, when the Ten Commandments were first proclaimed, Jehovah spoke audibly to Moses from Mount Sinai amid smoke, fire, thunder, and lightning, so that the assembled Israelites heard His voice. When the people saw the thunder and lightning and heard the trumpet and saw the mountain in smoke, they trembled with fear. They stayed at a distance and said to Moses, “Speak to us yourself and we will listen. But do not have God speak to us or we will die.” Then Moses said to the people, “Do not be afraid. God has come to test you, so that the fear of God will be with you to keep you from sinning.” Though this Biblical account is not up to Fuller’s seeing is believing, the Jewish belief about its happening makes them hold Jehovah’s diktats in dread. Whatever, in their God’s scheme of rewards and punishments there was no provision for recompense from sins through repentance.

But even when it comes to hearing,  it’s one thing for Jesus himself to claim to be the Son of God, that he never did, and yet another for his apostles to proclaim so, what with the innovative immaculate conception, added much later after his demise. So also, Jesus’ teachings, including the Sermon on the Mount as well as his “Go specifically to the lost sheep of Israel; don't enter Gentile, Samaritan towns” during his ministry and “Go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them and teaching them” that was after his resurrection (what did change in the meantime for his change of mind!), as cited in Mathew 10 and 28 respectively, have no evidentiary value whatsoever. It's thus, the entire Biblical legend of Jesus that is the fulcrum of the Christian faith is totally based on hearsay or improvement, as the case may be, but yet, the belief of the Christians in this regard is the gospel truth.

When it comes to the Islamic narrative, Gabriel, in incognito, met Muhammad in a cave of Mount Hira and made him say after him: “Recite in the name of thy Lord who created! He createth man from a clot of blood etc.” But as he fled from the cave in panic and was half-way down the hill, he heard a voice from above, “O Muhammad, thou art the Messenger of God, and I am Gabriel.” So, for his followers,  Muhammad’s word became the basis of their devotion for him and eventually the truth of Islam. Not only that, the guidance he said he received from Allah, the Arabic  avatar of Jehovah, became the ayats of the Quran to forever rule the minds of the Musalmans, for good or bad.

Just the same, it is this Semitic dogma that became its dictum; ‘the God’ revealed to their prophet the right ‘path of life’ for them to unquestioningly follow so as to stand the believers in good stead on the Day of Judgment. Besides, but for Judaism, in its religious offshoots of Christianity and Islam, the messiah is believed to be endowed with the power of intercession on behalf of the faithful on that Fateful Day. It’s thus, intended or otherwise, the prophet became the fulcrum of the faith as well as the icon of the Christian and the Islamic religious credos, relegating the otherwise haughty God to the fringes, never mind the pretence to the contrary.

It's another matter though that the Christians became antagonistic to Jews on the grouse that they were collectively responsible for Jesus’ death resulting in their persecution over the ages, culminating in the holocaust. That apart, so as to keep his flock together in the face of the Jewish mocking at his prophethood, Muhammad incited them against his detractors, the God’s chosen people. Not only that, so as to insulate his followers as well from the Christians, the acolytes of His son, he ordained them to keep away from the latter on the pretext that he (Jesus)  sought to partner with  Him along with Mary, his mother. Whatever, it is ironical that while the Unitary God had divided his flock into three mutually antagonistic factions, the Hindu gods and goddesses amalgamated the amorphous Sanatana  societies in their dharmic fold!

So, what of the peerless Hindu phenomenon, which the monotheists dismiss as idolatrous polytheism, that too even as the crosses with Jesus and his baby self in Mary’s arms abound in the Churches, and the Hajis fall over each other to kiss Hajar al-Aswad (Black Stone) at the Kabbah! If only the uninitiated realise, what they mistake as Hindu idol worship in essence is an obeisance to the deities in their distinctive vigrahas, in which their gods and goddesses get manifested (pranaprathista) through Vedic rituals, formulated in enchanting Sanskrit mantras.

Set aside their credos, what if we measure these four on the scale of gender justice that today’s man’s world pretends to hold dear. Whereas the Semitic dispensations are dictated by the Lord God (as already seen, Christianity had added Mary and Jesus in its pantheon to the chagrin of Islam), the Sanatana dharma is governed by spouse gods galore. Not only that, while the Semitic God is stern and aloof, Vishnu, the sustainer, (the creator Brahma and the destroyer  Shiva  being the others in the Trinity) in his avatars on earth, mingled with the Hindu folks. Won’t that fulfil Fuller’s twin criteria of seeing is believing, and feeling is the truth. What’s more, in respect of cultural aspects, while the solemn, even sombre, Semitic events, centred around the God and his prophets, for the most part that is, can almost be counted on the fingers of one hand, the numerous Hindu festivities, with mirth and music, associated with the gods and goddesses, nearly need a calculator to account for. And for those who experience it, that’s life, the blessed one at that.

All the same, for the discerning minds, the vital difference between the Sanatana dharma and the Semitic faiths lies in the concurrent philosophical stream of the former and the abject absence of the same in the latter that the Roberto Baggio episode amply underscores. Inconsolable at letting down Italy in that FIFA world cup final with his over-the-crossbar kick in the penalty shootout against Brazil, that too as its captain, and not finding any solace in ‘Jesus shedding his blood to save sinners’, he turned to Buddhism, a spiritual offshoot of Hinduism, for good effect.

What is amusing is that Christians and Muslims, whose God is not clear about the creation of man (see the tailpiece) seek to emancipate the Hindus whose progenitors had propositioned that it’s man who created the god, in theories many, as expostulated in the Brihadāranyaka Upanishad, composed around 700 B.C.E. Here’s is an excerpt from Valerie J. Roebuck’s The Upanisads, just to cite one such.

“He knew: “I am creation, for I created all this.” So he became creation. Whoever knows this, come to be in this, his creation.”

“When they say, “Sacrifice to that one!”, “Sacrifice to that one!”- some god or other, that is his varied creation, and he himself is all the gods.

Then he created from seed whatever is moist, and that is Soma. All this is just food and the eater of food. Soma is food, and Agni is the eater of food.

This is the higher creation of Brahma, since he created gods who are better than he: and also because, being mortal, he created immortals, it is his higher creation. Whoever knows this, comes to be in this, his higher creation.”

That’s not all; the Hindus have the Bhagavad-Gita, which according to the Prussian philosopher, William von Humboldt, “is the most beautiful, perhaps the only true philosophical song existing in any known tongue.” The author’s translation in verses, Bhagvad-Gita: Treatise of Self-help, is in the public domain that can be perused as free ebook, the essence of which is –   

“The Supreme Spirit through Nature causes the birth of all beings. Thus, the indwelling spirit in the beings is a divisible part of the same Indivisible Supreme Spirit. The spirit lying within beings is subject in degrees to virtue, passion and delusion, the three attributes of Nature. It should remain the human endeavor to free the indwelling spirit from these nature-induced influences. This, however, is not possible for any in a single birth, and indeed, it would take the sustained effort of lot many births for that. Thus, in the end, the soul could be tended towards that state of purity, which matches with that of the Supreme Spirit. As and when this happens, the indwelling spirit merges with the Supreme Spirit which is nothing but moksha.”

It's thus, the god is truly within man (aham brahmasmi) so also the so-called Satan, the salvation is not as simple as being or becoming a Christian or a Musalman, and the entry into heaven or the hereafter, as the case may be, is not based on the intercession of the messiah on the Day of Judgement. So, one may wake up and smell the coffee.  

The Tailpiece  

Clueless Creation,

A Satirical poem by the author.  

Told God man In Genesis One

Him He created in form of His

Not when asked as how He did

Thought He fit in Genesis Two

To tell He used the dust for that

But to change tack after that,

So in time Muhammad told

Made Jibrail recite him

In the name of One who makes

Man on earth from clot of blood,

Failed as he then to enquire

Wherefrom He gets all that blood

And since God hath sealed His mouth

Knows not man the true roots of his.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sunday, 27 September 2026


 SC ‘n ST (Prevention Of Atrocities) Act,

Or A Political Ploy of the Cynical Minds


Though for a long while, the dalits and the janjatis, aka SCs and STs, were wont to get the rough end of the social discriminatory stick, yet it was only forty years after independence that Rajiv Gandhi occasioned the SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act 1989, but not for any holistic reasons. It was but a cynical idea to stem the growing political mobilization of the dalits outside his congress umbrella that ensued the weakening of their traditional support to it from the early eighties. That was precisely because, by then, their social awakening, political empowerment and educational advancement, coupled with the country’s growing urbanization, made them assertive as a class and aggressive in their manners.

 

If anything, the ill-motivated SC and ST (Prevention Of Atrocities) Act that ironically came into force a year later on January 30, Gandhi’s death anniversary, in a way, gave the unscrupulous among the SC-STs the license to kill, not literally that is, just not in self-defense. It’s thus, the cynical law has squarely put the boot is the other leg, so to say, with statistical backing.

 

The official data pertaining to the complaints under the lopsided law and the convictions thereunder reads as under:

 

In 2022, while  57,569 cases were preferred by SCs, the ST count was 10,064 (put together 67,633); and the convictions during the year (including the ongoing trials from  previous years) was 34.1% and 28.1% respectively that is 31.1% in all. So, some 70% of the SC-ST complaints fell by the wayside, being unproven!

 

Likewise, in 2023, whereas 57,766 cases pertained to SCs, the ST proportion stood at 12,959 (70,725 combined) and so also the convictions during the year (reckoning the pending cases of previous years) added up to 32.4% and 24.6%  respectively, put together at 28.5%. So, again, 71.5% of the SC-ST accusations remained unsubstantiated!

 

Similarly, the case count for 2024 was, 55,685 of SCs and 9,961 of STs, together adding up to 65,646, a drop of 5,079. However, the conviction rates during the year(accounting for the previous years’ cases) came to 33.9% for SCs and 33.2% for STs, averaging 33.6% for both the categories. Thus, about 66.4% of the SC-ST cases did not result in conviction, although this represented an improvement in the conviction rate over the previous year.

 

However, as the average conviction rate in the three recent years came to 31%, it can be said without any contradiction that nearly 7 out of 10 SC-ST allegations failed to find traction in the country’s courts. What’s worse, while many of the innocent seven rotted in gaols for varied periods, for no fault of theirs, their accusers smiled all the way to their banks to collect the Sarkari ransom for their atrocities against the innocents!

 

All that is in the public domain but as they say, the devil is in the small print, and this is no exception.

 

As per the last census (2011), the SCs formed 20.14 crore and the STs, 10.42 crore of the country's total population of 121 crores, which means, they respectively made up 16.6%, and 8.6% of the populace, and together a quarter of it. So, by extrapolation, for the lack of an intervening census, in the 2022-24 period, they together would have made up some 60 crores out of the 140-crore envisaged population.

 

Just the same, the social dynamics are different in that out of 60 crore SC-STs, on an average, only 68,001 of them complained in each of the said three years that is a miniscule 0.113% of their ilk! What is more, given that only 31% of the SC-ST complaints led to convictions, the alleged atrocities against them would have been no more than 0.003% of their folks!! If it’s not making a caste mountain out of a social molehill, what else is this SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act? But therein lies the catch-22 of the Indian electoral politics.

 

Be that as it may, It is seldom appreciated that the atrocious media coverage of these odd complaints to the saturation levels has the inimical effect of othering these communities besides infusing a sense of victimhood in them. So, willy-nilly, it is as if to set up the conversion stage on the SC-ST ground for the proselytizers to poach the disgruntled into the alien faiths to nurture them in India’s Sanatan bosom.

 

And making it a double jeopardy for the Hindu society, as most of these complaints turn out to be false and fabricated, it’s but natural that the affected sections get further alienated from SC-STs as communities. If anything, that these politically pampered sections are being allowed to make money by dubious means completes the social schism, which is not in the national interest. But, sadly for our country, the moral cynicism has become the electoral compulsion of our political parties – they collectively alienate them from the rest even as they severally court them for political favours, for they form a quarter of the franchise.

 

If anything, the recent SC fiasco in IIT-Bombay has brought the devious Act’s dubious character to the fore like never before. Now, it is very much in the public domain that the morally corrupt as well as the legally savvy among SC-STs have been milking the State exchequer with profitable FIRs. Well, the notoriety the SC-ST ‘business model’ gained may ensure a plethora of new startups to the chagrin of the rest of the society. As for the political parties, it’s a case of ‘he who rides a tiger is afraid to dismount’. Maybe, VS Naipaul would have as well summed it up thus - India: A Million Miseries Now. So, it is imperative that India should apply its collective mind to nurse its ‘affected quarter’ to normal health, in the short term as well as in its long course.

 

So, the need of the hour is a multi-member high-power committee of eminences from the representative sections with the nationalist mindset and a pragmatic outlook, majority of them belonging to SC-ST communities, to come up with an equitable SC - ST Progression Act that is after taking the altered ground realities in the rural and the urban India into account. This is the short run, but to cover the long course, this author’s essay in the internet, Dali as Deva, à la Black is Beautiful can come in handy. Here under is an excerpt from it.

 

“Though the dalit tag affords political clout to its desperate classes as a whole, it had failed to buttress the self-worth of its disparate caste groups for in the Indian cultural calculus, caste is intrinsic to the social-worth of its members. Thus, it is imperative to cast a sense of caste-worth in the dalit fold in the ‘Black is Beautiful’ mould for the collective moral upliftment of its member castes.  But self-belief being the by-product of the zeal to strive and not a corollary of plucking low-hanging fruits, the system of reservations has effectually given a go-by to the zeal to excel, a vital ingredient of personality development. It is thus, the doles of the state inadvertently, but effectually, came to harm the dalit cause in the long run, and what’s worse, even the genuine dalit achievements entail a diminished stature for they come under the shadows set by low performance bars, thereby precluding their due social recognition at large. The way out, while yet retaining their quotas is for the dalits to volunteer to get their reservation bar raised to touch the prevailing positions.

 

 “What's in a name? That which we call a rose 

By any other name would smell as sweet,” 

said Shakespeare  but what he left unsaid  was 

‘And alike it makes any other name as rosy.’ 


Likewise, had the lexicologists named the Lord in the skies as Sod and an annoying guy on planet earth as God, the former name would’ve acquired divine connotations and the latter, a taboo word. Thus, it may be appreciated that a name is ‘worth neutral’ in its essence but becomes exalted or gets diminished depending on the object it’s associated with, which, in turn, is the subject of our subjective attributions. And the same applies to the caste names that came to represent the ascending steps of the Hindu social ladder for the demeaned Mala indeed sounds better than the exulted Brahmin, the denigrated Madiga is easy on the ear than the extolled Maratha, the dismissed Chamar is more sonorous than the domineering Choudhary et al. Hence, for an Indian variant of Black is Beautiful movement, it is essential for the members of the depressed castes to begin taking pride in their respective castes and suffix their caste name to their social name with the same sense of pride as Yadavs, Reddys etc. resort to. Indeed, as Manda Krishna Madiga of Madiga Reservation Porata Samithi , so to say, has given the lead in this direction, the other castes in the dalit fold should follow suit wearing their caste worth on their sleeves.”